Click here for full manuscript
"Where Does Our Story Begin?" is a Parishioner's Pick sermon that grew out of a dinner-table question: when did Christianity actually start? The preacher opens by saying a sermon is meant to be "a door, not a wall," the start of thinking rather than the end of it. He then imagines the Ponder family and a friend from another church around a Sunday dinner table. Each offers a different answer, and each has Scripture on their side.
Granny says it began when Jesus died and didn't stay dead. Drawing on 1 Corinthians 15, she argues that without the resurrection our faith is futile, because death is the one thing nothing else gets past.
The friend from another church points to Pentecost (Acts 2). The resurrection is the foundation, but Pentecost is when the church became a visible people that others could join. When Peter called the crowd to repent and be baptized, three thousand responded.
Brother goes back to Jesus calling the fishermen (Matthew 4). The resurrection needed witnesses, and the disciples followed a person before they understood where he would lead.
Mom turns to the incarnation and Mary's courageous "let it be to me" (Luke 1). Before Jesus could be anyone's Lord, he had to be somebody's baby. The Word became flesh.
Dad reaches back to God's promises: the first gospel in Genesis 3, then Abraham, David, and Isaiah 53. Mary said yes to something God had been promising since the garden.
Sister suggests they're all starting too late. Citing Ephesians 1 and John 1, she argues that Christianity may have no first domino at all. It reflects who God has always been, chosen "before the foundation of the world."
Aunt quietly agrees with everyone, but adds that none of it became hers until her baptism (Romans 6). History has to become biography: the day Christianity started is different from the day it starts in you.
Dad wraps up by honoring each person's insight. He concludes that they weren't really arguing; each was holding a different piece of the same story. Maybe the real question isn't "when did it start?" but "where do I enter it?" The story begins again every time someone says yes, as Mary did and as Aunt did at the water. He closes the evening in prayer, thanking God for every part of the story and for the fact that it isn't finished.
